Thursday, November 27, 2008

The Politics of Dress Sense?

I think something is wrong with me. There's a type of (usually) white person that drives me insane. I don't altogether know why. This 'type' is perhaps best summarised as the sort of people who tend to be Drama students my age. I say 'white person,' but that is purely by-the-by. The fact of their being white may simply arise from the fact that my university is a Muslim hub - and hence virtually everyone studying an Arts subject seems to be white.

When I say my university is a Muslim hub, I mean it. Let the words be taken at face value, with no extra layers of prejudice or analysis. It is filled with girls wearing hijabs - a garment so expressive of a certain attitude (particularly towards faith) that even having a sports commentator strapped to one's skull could not compete. There are also a few guys with the little prayer-caps (sorry, I don't know what they're called) and the large beards. Need I characterise the mindset that accompanies such an overt expression of faith? - I think not. Suffice it to say that girls draped chin-to-ankle in carefully concealing fabric are REALLY unlikely to be doing Drama - a subject that requires costume changes, flexibility of appearance and even nudity.

No, (not unlike many South Asians...) most of these girls and boys will be studying things like Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences. Chances are that if they're in Languages, they plan on teaching afterwards. In a lot of cases, it's not really their fault - they'd have to fight big-time in order to diverge. Much as I did. So when I see the sort of university sweatshirt and Ugg-boot-wearing blonde-haired guffawing girls (or their tight-jean and striped-cardigan-sporting male equivalent), a powerful and irrational dislike fills my heart.

I think it is their uniformity that annoys me. That universal uniform of the undeservedly comfortable. Ugg boots don't come cheap, and neither does make-up, good-quality or no (I don't even want to think about how much MAC, beloved of two of my mates and probably more people, costs on a regular basis). It is a uniform of aspiration, based on aping people like fucking Alexa Chung and Sloane Ranger-type girls. It is a uniform that says: 'I don't have to worry about getting a real job, because I am white and middle-class, and ultimately I rule this country.' A sense of entitlement radiates from the whole bloody thing.

I hate tribalism, and seeing it signalled in a common 'uniform' makes me uneasy. I feel similarly oppressed around 'typical Asians' - girls with their love of black, tiny-skinny bodies and coloured contact lenses, guys with their oh-so-enterprising minor designer/sportswear brand-blending and gelled-porcupine heads. The way you dress is a statement, I suppose. Some people balk at 'chavvy' sportswear, gold hoop earrings and Burberry sportswear - well, I balk at the cut-off denim minis with black footless tights! I balk at the 'ethnic' scarves and the proliferation of black, brown, denim and if you're lucky, monochrome!

For me, it represents the ugly delusion of the youth of today. Here are all these girls and boys who (to me), are emblematic of an increasingly apathetic and anti-intellectual society. Why do you keep blindly taking what the celebrities, celebrity-worshipping sites, shops and magazines dole out to you? Why in the fuck do you want to look like the ever-vacuous Peaches Geldof? Why don't you descend on the shops and ask them why they keep making clothes for the likes of Agyness Deyn and Alice Dellal? There are plenty of boys and girls - white and non-white - who don't fit the fashionable norm, and instead of trying to bridge reality a little, Fashion simply pounces upon girls like Jourdan Dunn, who, although beautiful, still represent Europeanised ideas of beauty and the ideal shape.

Why on Earth am I getting so worked up over what people wear? - because it matters! In a heavily-mediatised, visually-obsessed age such as is ours, it MATTERS more than ever! Perhaps because the speed of change is so great these days, that young people dress safer and more formal because they start having to 'grow up' sooner. Or maybe they can't be bothered to rebel. Maybe I sound like a fashion-fascist, but I think it's a shame. Why? Your youth is supposed to be a time of experimentation and craziness! Maybe it is simply a sign of the times; maybe people are so sick of gnawing upon their future prospects amid The Impending End of The World (aka the never-ending financial crisis) that risk is (and has been) dying out in the search for stability...

Or maybe the amount of introspection, analysis and obsessive-symbol-seeking of my degree is driving me insane, and I need to get a life?

I will probably post some related thing at some point soon, trying to explain a bit more why I feel this way. In the meantime, I will let VICE sum it up for me (replacing 'New York' with 'London', of course).

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

"I feel similarly oppressed around 'typical Asians' - girls with their love of black, tiny-skinny bodies and coloured contact lenses"

++++++

You know what? I think you're a snob. It's you that is unable to see past the superficialities of someone's appearance and at least allow them an individual existence. Because you define yourself so much against other Asians, your whole existence seemingly an never ending rage against people you don't want to be associated with, you become superficial yourself. Why do you think you're an individual? Because you can mention a few brand names and dress in a style different to others (but very much like millions of other women of your age -- whoops!)

You come across as a nice person, but you aren't half a condescending snob sometimes. Your style is ten a penny, but I guess, as long as you have Asians to moan about, and endlessly repeat, in block capitals, your difference from, the illusion of uniqueness and originality passes in the sheer volume of your screams.

- Jo -

KJB said...

You know what? I AM a snob, and I've never tried to claim otherwise!

I love your misguided anger - I never try to stop anyone from having 'an individual existence.'

'Why do you think you're an individual?'

At what point did I say that I 'thought this'? Do not pass go and do not collect £200.

'your whole existence seemingly an never ending rage against people you don't want to be associated with...'

Nice try, pseudo-Freud!

I am quite confused about the block capitals. Where, pray tell, are they?

If you'd actually READ the post, you'd see that I'm not trying to tell anyone what to do, just wishing that people would take more pleasure in 'superficialities' because life ain't easy.

Try actually reading through and thinking twice next time. Ta for now!

andy gilmour said...

Evening.

Speaking as someone who can seem a bit monochromatic..what's so terribly wrong with brown? :-))

Just 'cos you've got the panache & youthful vigour [:-)] to carry off bright colours, doesn't mean that a pleasing range of 'earth tones' (aka "mud", "slightly lighter mud", "grubby off-white " and "none more black" [copyright This Is Spinal Tap]) don't work just fine for us almost-40 blokes :-))

Mind you, I do have a couple of red things hiding away in the cupboard, but they're a bit scared...

Yours, missing the point in an entirely deliberate fashion,

Andy

saki said...

I got me a purple belt! It goes with my purple scarf! Got some classy brown gloves and little green scarf thing too. Would quite like some new jeans though...

Clothes are tribal, they help people in their identity creation and to fit in or to make a statement that they do not fit in. I judge people on their clothes and they judge me, consciously or not. I am a shallow shallow bastard, or I just care too much about the aesthetic. I do also know I dress more for myself than for anyone else, and whilst clothes don't equal personality, they along with a lot of other things are an easy shortcut to aspects of personality, not their sensitivity or kindness perhaps, but perhaps their cultural sensitivity (meant in the sense of appreciation of art rather than cultural difference).

I have just come back from clubby club, so my thoughts are abstracted and I have managed to miss my mouth with my glass of water.

Anyways, peace and fucking.
Tot Straks, Doei!

Anonymous said...

When I was at uni, I didn't like those people either, the ones on Arts courses who never seemed to need to worry about working for a living.

I guess it takes a lot of time and also guts to dress differently from the crowd. I deliberately grew my hair long for the sake of going to University and being just like everyone else my age. After years of having short hair. Sometimes it's good to just blend into the crowd. Never underestimate the benefits of passing for normal.

Please explain more about how you feel about Asians with headscarves? You haven't really explained what you think about them. From a white woman in her thirties. x

KJB said...

@ Andy:

Lol. I just want people to show a little flair! I'm not forcing them, but it can be quite fun. As I said in my first comment, it's not just about clothes, but about taking more pleasure in small things... and evidently you are a bit of a foodie/photographer, so you are forgiven :-P.

@ saki:

I know... I know...

Haha. The green scarf sounds excitin'! And no, you are perfectly sensible/coherent etc.

@ Anonymous:

'Sometimes it's good to just blend into the crowd. Never underestimate the benefits of passing for normal.'

Amen.

I will attempt to write another post on my feelings regarding Asians with headscarves at some point soon...

Fab said...

@ Anonymous:

Well, I'm sorry but some people choose not to work and to live on benefits after their Arts degree. So what?

Maybe they have different views than you on life. They made different choices. They refuse to live a life centered around stressful paid work that devours almost the entirety of your time.

Work is not the alpha and the omega of life, for some people at least.

Ala said...

That makes me a unique hybrid in your categorisations. I was an artsy arts student, but in a headscarf! I did the whole non-conformist dressing, but most of the time I was too poor to buy clothes so did my non-conformism by wearing the same rags day in day out. It was the dark ages so I couldn't buy funky clothes off the internet. Now that I can buy funky clothes off the internet, I spend most of my money on smart clothes for interviews and most of my time wearing smart clothes for intervriews. But I'm still non-conformist in spirit!